

It's Always the Quiet Ones
A case folder stamped Confidential. It's always the quiet ones.
Christmas gift A gift for the true crime fan who always guesses the ending. Order by mid-December so it arrives before Christmas. Amazon shows the delivery date before you pay.
Opens Amazon in a new tab. You'll choose size and color there, and Amazon handles shipping and returns. Prices can change on Amazon.
Wearing it? Tag @genuinebyanthony (opens Instagram in a new tab) on Instagram.
About It's Always the Quiet Ones
IT'S ALWAYS above and THE QUIET ONES below a worn manila case folder stamped Confidential in red, with a fingerprint, a paper evidence tag and a bit of red string.
It's for true crime podcast fans, documentary bingers and the friend who always guesses the killer in the first ten minutes. It comes from ColdCase Party, the online murder mystery game.
It comes as a soft tri-blend tee and a Comfort Colors heavyweight tee.
Want to play detective for real? Host a murder mystery at ColdCase Party (opens in a new tab)
- Confidential case folder with an evidence tag
- It's Always the Quiet Ones
- Tri-blend tee and Comfort Colors heavyweight tee
- Murder mystery night
- True crime podcasts
- Game night
- Book club
- Styles
- Tri-blend tee and heavyweight tee
- Collection
- True Crime
- Price
- $20.99 to $24.99 on Amazon
- Printing
- Printed to order by Amazon Merch on Demand
- Sizes and colors
- Chosen on Amazon after you pick a style
- Shipping and returns
- Handled by Amazon
- Holiday returns
- Amazon's holiday window: most items bought November 1 to December 31 can be returned until January 31, 2027
Style details
Tri-blend T-shirt $20.99
- Lightweight, extra soft 40 singles tri-blend: 50% polyester, 25% cotton, 25% rayon
- Classic crew neck with side-seam construction
- Lighter colors are semi-sheer
- Machine wash
Comfort Colors heavyweight tee $24.99
- 100% cotton, soft-washed and garment-dyed for a lived-in feel
- Relaxed fit in adult unisex sizes. Size up for an oversized look
- Printed in the USA on imported materials
- Machine wash
See the heavyweight tee on Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab)
From Amazon's listings. Fabric blends vary by color, so check the listing for the color you pick.